In this heartfelt and nuanced middle-grade novel, A.J. Sass introduces readers to Shai Stern, a thirteen-year-old nonbinary, neurodivergent teen navigating the complexities of identity, mental health, and cultural heritage. Set in the Northwoods of Wisconsin, Shai embarks on a journey to establish a "new normal" by transitioning from homeschooling to public school, coming out as genderfluid, and exploring their Jewish roots.

As Shai faces the challenges of skipping a grade, forming new friendships, and managing anxiety manifested through compulsive skin-picking, they also delve into their family's Jewish history for a school project. This exploration leads to a deeper understanding of their heritage and the realization that embracing one's full identity is a multifaceted process.